Home

Unit 3: Animals and the moral circle

3.4 Could we be in the middle of a moral catastrophe?

Lesson 4 of 4 in this unit · 7 min

Go back to Pythion's epitaph. The people who carved it were not monsters by their own lights. Nearly every society that committed what we now see as a grave moral wrong did so while believing itself decent.

The philosopher Evan G. Williams draws an uncomfortable conclusion from this: we are probably no different. There is likely something we do now, at scale, that future generations will regard as a catastrophe. We might be wrong about who counts, or about what is acceptable to do to them. His argument rests on a simple piece of arithmetic.

Try it

Suppose there are a number of major moral questions our society could be getting wrong, and you're quite confident we've got each one right. What's the chance we've got all of them right?

%

Chance we're right on all of them

46%

At 95% confidence on each of 15 questions, the chance of being right on all of them is about 46%. This assumes the questions are independent, which is a simplification.

Source: Linch Zhang's summary of Evan G. Williams, "The Possibility of an Ongoing Moral Catastrophe" (2015), EA Handbook chapter 3

Williams doesn't say which practice is the catastrophe. He argues that we should take moral questions more seriously as a research problem, and avoid irreversible steps while we're uncertain.

Where the case for prioritising farmed animals is weakest.

  • Moral weight. If animal experiences count for very little, the case falls away whatever the numbers. Many thoughtful people hold this view.
  • Durability. It is unclear whether reforms such as cage-free housing lead to lasting change, or only improve a system that stays largely the same. Advocates themselves disagree about reform versus abolition.
  • Tractability. Diets, farming livelihoods and food culture change slowly, and political resistance can be strong. That is visible in Dutch debates about livestock numbers.

Kelsey Piper, a journalist who writes about effective altruism, poses a test for any movement that claims to be doing good: would it have got the big moral questions of its own time right?

Exercise
Saved0 / 1,000

Saved only in this browser. EAN can't see it.

After Kelsey Piper, "On 'fringe' ideas", EA Handbook chapter 3

Tip: use the left and right arrow keys to move between lessons.