Home
Questions and answers

Common questions, honest answers

What people ask us most about effective altruism, including the objections. We've kept the answers short and linked to more where it helps.

New to all this? Start with What is effective altruism?

In short

Five things people often get wrong

  1. It's a question, not a list of answers
  2. It isn't only about donating
  3. You decide how much you do
  4. Disagreement is welcome
  5. You don't have to join anything

Each of these comes up below.

The idea

What is effective altruism?

What is effective altruism?

It's the project of working out how to help others as much as possible, using evidence and careful reasoning, and then acting on what you find.

It's a field of research, which tries to identify the world's most pressing problems and the best ways to tackle them. It's also a community of people who use that research in their careers, their giving and their free time.

Isn't that just common sense?

The idea sounds obvious. Doing it is rare. Most of us give to a cause, or choose a job, because something happened to cross our path and moved us. Few of us stop to compare the options first.

Effective altruism adds that one step: of everything I could do, what would help the most?

Are you saying what I do now isn't effective?

We don't know, and we're not judging. Careers, charities and causes differ hugely in how much good they do, so if you've never compared your options it would be lucky to have landed on the best one. That's true for all of us.

The good news is that whatever you do now, a bit of comparing will probably show you a way to do more.

Does it only back things that are proven to work?

No. Some people prefer approaches with strong evidence behind them, such as bed nets against malaria. Others back work that's less certain but could matter much more if it succeeds, such as developing a new vaccine or making advanced AI safer.

Both have a place. What they share is careful reasoning about the chance of success and the size of the payoff.

What if I disagree with what effective altruists recommend?

Then you're in good company. Effective altruism is a way of thinking, not a fixed list of recommendations, and people in the community disagree with each other all the time about which problems and approaches are best.

Conclusions change when better arguments or evidence come along. If you have a thoughtful criticism, people will want to hear it.

How do you compare very different kinds of good?

With difficulty, and with humility. In global health there are established measures, such as years of healthy life gained, that let you compare very different diseases.

Comparing across areas is harder. How do you weigh a child spared from malaria against a hen spared from a cage, or a lower risk of a future pandemic? Researchers are working on better tools for this. Nobody claims the answers are precise, but a rough comparison still beats none.

The problems

Which problems, and why those?

Which problems do people work on?

Many. The three you'll hear about most are global health and development, animal welfare, and global catastrophic risks such as pandemics and advanced AI.

There's no central plan. People reach different conclusions and work on plenty of other things too, from climate to mental health to better policy-making.

Why focus on some problems more than others?

Because nobody has the time or money to work on everything. So people ask three questions about a problem. How big is it? How neglected is it? And how solvable is it?

A problem that is large, gets little attention and has workable solutions is one where your extra effort goes furthest.

Why global health and development?

Millions of people still die every year from illnesses we know how to prevent or treat, and many more live in extreme poverty. There are well-tested ways to help that cost very little per person.

The best of these do far more good per euro than typical ones. Researchers at GiveWell estimate their top charities save a life for roughly $3,500 to $5,500.

Why animal welfare?

More than 80 billion land animals are raised and killed for food each year, and far more fish. Most live on factory farms, in conditions that cause a great deal of suffering.

There are effective ways to improve this, such as campaigns for better welfare standards and work on alternative proteins. Yet very little money goes to it compared with the size of the problem.

Why risks from artificial intelligence?

AI is getting more capable quickly. It could bring enormous benefits, and also serious harm, whether through misuse or through systems we can't reliably control.

The number of people working to make AI safe is still small next to what's at stake. That's why many in the community see it as an area where extra people and funding matter a lot.

Is it all about future generations?

No. Some people focus on problems of today, some on the long-term future, and many care about both.

The case for the future is simple: far more people may yet be born than have ever lived, and their lives matter too. People moved by this often work on reducing risks that could harm both us and them, such as pandemics, nuclear war and unsafe AI.

Can I apply it to a cause I already care about?

Yes. Within any cause, some approaches and organisations achieve much more than others, and you can use evidence to find them.

It's also worth staying open. Looking at how big, neglected and solvable different problems are sometimes shows people that their time or money would go further somewhere they hadn't considered.

Objections

The criticisms we hear most

Is it only about earning money and giving it away?

No. Giving is one way to help. Others are working directly on a problem, doing research, shaping policy or volunteering.

In the early years, 'earning to give' (taking a well-paid job in order to donate more) got more attention than it deserved. It was always one option among many, and career advice in the community now covers a much wider range of paths.

Is it the same as utilitarianism?

No. Plenty of utilitarians like effective altruism, but so do people who think in terms of duties, virtues, rights or their faith. It doesn't hold that the ends justify the means, and it doesn't excuse harming people for a greater good.

It asks you to accept only two things: that helping others matters, and that, all else equal, helping more is better than helping less.

Does it ignore systemic change?

Less than critics think. It's true that many people favour interventions whose results can be measured and compared. But a lot of work in the community is about changing systems: policy, regulation, research and advocacy. One example is working with governments to get lead out of paint.

What you'll find less of is work aimed at replacing whole systems, such as capitalism. That's partly because it's so hard to know whether it would work, or what else it would bring.

What if everyone did this? Wouldn't other causes be abandoned?

The advice changes as the world does. If a neglected problem started getting plenty of attention and money, extra help there would achieve less, and people would rightly look elsewhere.

We're a long way from that. The problems the community works on are still short of people and funding.

Isn't it cold and calculating?

It starts with caring. People get involved because they're moved by suffering that could be prevented, and then they do the sums because they want their help to reach as many as possible.

The numbers serve the compassion. They don't replace it.

Isn't it too demanding?

How much you do is up to you. Effective altruism is about making whatever you give, in time or money, count for more. It doesn't set a minimum.

Nobody benefits when you wear yourself out. Most people in the community have ordinary lives, with hobbies, friends and families, and many say that doing good this way has given them a sense of purpose.

Shouldn't we help people in the Netherlands first?

There's nothing wrong with helping close to home, and many people in the community do both. But a euro goes much further in a low-income country, where basic health care costs a fraction of what it does here.

People nearby don't matter less. The same gift simply helps more people elsewhere.

Does aid really work?

Some of it works remarkably well and a lot of it doesn't. That gap is the whole point: because the difference between the best and the average is so large, it pays to look for the best.

And aid is only one route. Research, policy and starting new organisations can do a great deal of good too.

Is it just about picking the cheapest option?

No. What counts is how much good each euro does, and a cheap programme that achieves nothing is poor value. Sometimes the best option is expensive and still worth it.

Isn't this the job of governments and billionaires?

They have a big part to play, and many people in the community work to improve how governments and large funders spend. But they don't cover everything, and the needs are far larger than what they provide.

Individual donors also fund things that large institutions overlook or can't support. So the useful question isn't who ought to pay. It's what your own contribution can do.

Do the people being helped get a say?

They should, and help that ignores them usually works worse. Organisations handle this in different ways. GiveDirectly gives cash and leaves the choices to the people receiving it. Others ask people what they value, or provide things such as vaccines whose benefit is rarely in doubt.

It's harder when those affected can't be asked, as with animals or people not yet born. There, researchers do their best to work out what they would want.

Does it neglect what's hard to measure?

It's a real risk, and people in the community take it seriously. If you only count what's easy to count, you'll miss important work.

Measurement is one tool among several. You can't run a trial on preventing a pandemic, yet many people work on exactly that. They reason about how bad the outcome could be, how likely it is, and how a project is supposed to make a difference.

Is the community too homogeneous?

It's less diverse than it should be. The movement began at universities in wealthy countries, and surveys show it still leans highly educated, well-off and secular.

That's changing as it grows, and views inside the community vary more than you might expect on politics, religion and how to live. We want people from every background to feel welcome with us. If you don't, we'd like to hear about it.

Who is in charge of effective altruism?

Nobody. It's a loose network of local groups, researchers, charities and individuals who share some principles and often disagree on the details. You don't sign up and there's no membership.

Some organisations support the community. The Centre for Effective Altruism runs conferences and helps groups worldwide, and EA Netherlands does that work here. Neither of us speaks for everyone.

Careers

Doing good with your work

What is a high-impact career?

One where your work helps solve an important problem that needs more people, money or research. That can mean working on the problem directly, or supporting those who do.

Do I need to work at an effective altruism organisation?

No. Most people who do a lot of good don't. You can have an impact in government, research, business or at any organisation working on something that matters, and through giving or volunteering alongside your job.

Can I switch without starting over?

Often, yes. Organisations working on pressing problems need the skills you already have: operations, finance, software, communications, research, management.

A good first step is to talk to people who've made the move. That's much of what our community is for.

Where do I find roles?

Our jobs board gathers high-impact jobs, internships and programmes that you can do in or from the Netherlands.

Can someone help me think it through?

Yes. Book a free video call with our team and we'll talk through where you are and what a next step could be. If you'd like to go deeper, Probably Good offers free one-to-one career advice.

Giving

Giving from the Netherlands

I already pay taxes. Why give more?

What you do with your money is your call. But taxes mostly pay for things in the Netherlands, and some of the world's biggest problems are ones that governments aren't set up to solve. That's where giving can do a lot.

If you have room to give and want to, it makes sense to give where it helps most.

What if I don't have much to give?

Then give what feels comfortable, or nothing for now. You shouldn't get into trouble in order to donate, and there are other ways to help.

Small gifts do count, though. And you may be richer than you think: a single person on the modal Dutch salary is richer than about 97% of the world's people.

How do I know where my donation helps most?

You don't have to work it out alone. Independent evaluators spend thousands of hours a year comparing charities and publish what they find: GiveWell for global health, Animal Charity Evaluators for animals, Giving Green for climate.

How do I give effectively from the Netherlands?

The simplest way is Doneer Effectief. It's a Dutch non-profit where you give to proven, highly effective charities in one place, in euros. The charities are picked using independent evaluators, and it's recognised as an ANBI.

If you'd like company, De Geefrevolutie brings givers together over drinks, dinners and talks. It's relaxed and you don't need to give a set amount. Its site and events are in Dutch.

Can I deduct my donations from Dutch tax?

Often, yes. Gifts to an ANBI can be deducted from your income tax. One-off gifts count only above a threshold. If you agree in writing to give a fixed amount each year for at least five years, the whole gift is deductible.

Our giving guide explains both routes. Check the Belastingdienst for the current rules.

Should I give to one charity or to a fund?

Either works. Giving to a charity directly means you choose it yourself. With a fund, your gift is pooled with others and experts decide where it's needed most at that moment, which is handy if you'd rather not follow the research.

GiveWell, Animal Charity Evaluators, Giving Green and Effective Altruism Funds all run funds.

What is the 10% Pledge?

A public promise to give 10% of your income to the charities you think do the most good. More than 10,000 people around the world have taken it through Giving What We Can, including hundreds in the Netherlands. There's also a trial pledge if you'd like to start smaller.

Getting involved

Effective altruism in the Netherlands

What is EA Netherlands?

We're the national organisation for effective altruism in the Netherlands. We help people learn about the ideas, meet each other and act on them.

It started in 2017 with a small group. Today hundreds of people take part, in nine cities and online. We run the EA Fellowship and a quick online course, organise events, support local groups, keep a jobs board and host a co-working space in Amsterdam.

Read more

What has effective altruism achieved so far?

A few examples. Donors following GiveWell's research have funded work estimated to have saved hundreds of thousands of lives. Ambitious Impact has started more than 40 charities. The Open Wing Alliance has helped get 250 million more hens out of cages since 2013.

In the Netherlands, the community helped give rise to Doneer Effectief, De Geefrevolutie, the School for Moral Ambition and Safe AI Netherlands.

Why join a community at all?

You can do a lot of good on your own. But most people find it easier, and more fun, with others. You learn faster, you hear about opportunities, you get honest feedback on your plans, and you stay motivated.

There's no membership and nothing to sign. Come once and see if it suits you.

Where can I meet people?

There are local and student groups in nine Dutch cities, plus talks, workshops and socials across the country. If you'd like a place to work among like-minded people, you can apply to use our co-working space in Amsterdam.

Where should I start?

If you have a couple of hours, take our quick online course. It's free, you go at your own pace and you don't need to sign up.

If you want to go deeper, apply for the EA Fellowship: five weeks in a small group with an experienced facilitator, working through a real career or giving decision. It's free but selective.

Do I have to call myself an effective altruist?

No. Many people who come to our events or use these ideas wouldn't use the label, and that's fine. Take what's useful.

My question isn't here. Who can I ask?

Us. Book a call with our team or send us a message. For detailed questions, the Effective Altruism Forum is a good place to ask the wider community.

Still have a question?

Ask us. We're happy to talk through a doubt, an objection or your next step on a short video call.

The questions follow the Centre for Effective Altruism's FAQ. The answers are ours.